X-Men #41
Recap
The Chairman has erected a force-field dome around Juniper, containing his "mistake," while Cyclops has wandered in to confront his friend’s evil twin, leaving the X-Men on the outside.
Review
Contrary to popular belief, it is not that fun to bag on an ongoing title (especially on a biweekly basis), but Jed MacKay’s X-Men has been on a consistent spiral of quality with what seems to be a stubbornly downward trajectory. This is in spite of a handful of interesting ideas and plot hooks, usually ones that go nowhere so we can do the Age of Revelation thing again and again and again.
There is just so much dialogue in X-Men #41, and most of it is absolutely meaningless to the overall story of the issue or the DNX event. Very little new information comes to light as MacKay continues reheating the same meal over and over again before cutting the crust off. On the other hand, the rest of the dialogue is just characters declaring their own backstory or abilities in the middle of an action sequence for what feels like the twentieth time in a row.
Most of the characterization in the issue is banal to the point of eliciting the heaviest of sighs. Juggernaut is handled rather well, given his problems back in issue #34, for about two pages until he disappears. And then there is Psylocke, whose writing is more of the same “I’m an assassin, didn’t you know that?” that MacKay has been shoving into the past four issues or so. The heavy hitters around, like Kid Omega and Magneto, are relegated to the background and occasional quips because if MacKay paid any attention to them, the story would resolve itself rather quickly.
Netho Diaz, JP Mayer, and Sean Parsons’ art is hit or miss. Some pages have a strong sense of motion and excellent camerawork, while others are lacking in similar details. It’s clear both artists are extremely talented yet likely had very little time to meet their deadlines for parts of this issue. Still, the characters are given care and attention by the line art, which enhances the read considerably.
Hesli and Sánchez-Almara’s colors help on the more detailed pages while remaining serviceable on the rest of the issue where the pages that feel rushed. Special effects and superpowers are colored well and have enough flair to avoid complete boredom, but half the time the colors don’t have anything new to do and are forced to show us the same thing over and over again, which hampers their ability to improve the visual storytelling.
Final Thoughts
X-Men #41 is simply not a good single issue and its quality seems indicative of the entire current run on X-Men. Jed MacKay is not a bad author, but a biweekly comic and forced event have brought out some of the worst of his storytelling.
X-Men #41: Round and Round We Go
- Writing - 3.5/103.5/10
- Storyline - 4.5/104.5/10
- Art - 7/107/10
- Color - 7/107/10
- Cover Art - 7/107/10