Nightwing #144
Recap
IT'S TIME FOR A SHOWDOWN! At last, Nightwing confronts Mayor Bisogni, the mastermind responsible for building the superhighway that awakened Blüdhaven's buried horrors — and unveils another tale of familial legacy, psychological cruelty and... cheeseburgers?
Also from Comic Watch...
Review
The Blüdhaven super highway continues to dredge up and magnify many of the city’s worst elements in Nightwing #144. No matter what Nightwing does, he can’t heal what seems to be a malignant tumor on the city. Perhaps the only person who can heal Blüdhaven is the man who greenlit the super highway in the first place–Blüdhaven’s Mayor Bisogni.
Nightwing #144 opens with the titular character in the middle of stopping a carjacking. There’s nothing particularly special about the carjacking–it’s a normal crime as far as Blüdhaven goes. But like so much that goes wrong in the city lately, one of the perpetrators is an otherwise ordinary man desperate to get away from the super highway. His neighborhood was torn down to make room for it, his apartment backs right up to it, and the sound of the cars keeps him up all night.
Enter Mayor Bisogni. That night he convinces Nightwing to follow him down the highway, off on to dilapidated back roads, and to a closed and beaten down fast food restaurant. The issue largely plays out in this setting, and the first major confrontation between Nightwing and the mayor is one of philosophies. Bisogni’s argument boils down to the idea that people need to be shepherded away from bad behavior and ultimately taken care of by their leaders. The super highway is a part of that plan. Unsurprisingly, Nightwing takes the opposite position–everyone has free will and should make their own choices, including choices that might bring them to believe as Bisongi does.
Watters very effectively turns the super highway story on its ear. To this point Biogni has been played as a strict black hat, having intentionally caused all the problems that were born out of the super highway. Bisogni actually has a more complicated agenda. His behavior will certainly not make him sympathetic, but Nightwing #144 makes him a much more complicated character. There is a darkness at the center of Bisogni, but at the same time he is a kind of victim himself.
Comics like Nightwing #144–comics that consist almost entirely of dialogue between characters–are heavily dependent on those characters’ visual depiction. Emoting, or rather the lack thereof, has been a failing of this series for several issues. This is especially the case with Nightwing who is often drawn with a static presentation and minimal expressive variety.
Cowan’s depiction of Nightwing is considerably improved in this issue, though. The character displays considerably more emotion here. Much of this owes to the varied distances at which Nightwing appears in panels. When Nightwing is repeatedly of the same relative distance in the panel, Cowan’s depiction of him appears almost cut and paste. In this issue Nightwing is frequently further away and many times in panels with other characters. The result is Cowan delivering a much more expressive Nightwing who is displaying a wider variety of emotions, especially stress and anger.
Bisogni, on the other hand, is drawn as the picture of composure. The character’s facial expressions are somewhat flat, but his eyes are communicative. It’s a presentation that works very well for the character.
There is a nice transition of colors over the course of the issue. Nightwing #144 opens on a bright day. It transitions to twilight as Nightwing and Bisogni drive through the city. When the pair reach the fast food joint, they are bathed in an almost sickly pink inside before finally transitioning to a deadly red. It’s a good mood setter throughout.
Abbott does a good job keeping the high volume of dialogue bubbles and caption boxes in this issue well organized. A lot of what’s communicated in Nightwing #144 is via character appearance and expression, and Abbott’s lettering never gets in the way of that art.
Final Thoughts
NIghtwing #144 is the best kind of confrontation between a hero and villain–a confrontation of ideas. It also adds considerable depth to Mayor Bisogni, explaining why he did what he did beyond simple villainy. Combined with improved visuals when it comes to characters, especially on Nightwing himself, Nightwing #144 is distinctly complex among recent issues and a good place for new readers to check out the series.
Nightwing #144: Chatting Up the Bad Guy
- Writing - 8.5/108.5/10
- Storyline - 8/108/10
- Art - 7.5/107.5/10
- Color - 7.5/107.5/10
- Cover Art - 8/108/10