Site icon Comic Watch

X-Men: Incursions #1: Kate, Ebeneezer, and a Strange Carol

8.3/10

X-Men: Incursions #1

Artist(s): Jim Towe

Colorist(s): Fer Sifuentes-Sujo

Letterer: Clayton Cowles

Publisher: Marvel Comics

Genre: Action, Magic, Marvel Comics, Sci-Fi, Superhero, Supernatural

Published Date: 11/18/2026

Recap

The moments where two universes collide are known as Incursions in the Marvel multiverse and they’ve been the subject of line wide events and storylines for decades. X-Men: Incursions #1 brings together three realities from past events out of Marvel’s backlog as the backdrop for a very human story. Briefly, the three realities at play here are:

House of M (2005) is an alternate reality created by Scarlet Witch where her father Magneto is King of a mutant society. "Days of Future Past" (1981) is a mutant doomsday where the mutant race have been hunted to the brink of extinction. Secret Wars (2015) sees Doctor Doom rule as the God-Emperor of Battleworld from the 1984 version of the event with new stories.

Review

Warning: Spoilers for the storyline of X-Men: Incursions #1. Reading the issue before this review is recommended.

There are few conceivable fates worse than the complete and utter obliteration of your world. Your home, your loved ones, your dreams.

X-Men: Incursions #1 explores the single moment before oblivion and everything a character like Kitty/Kate Pryde, often one of the most human X-Men, would want to know in her final moments. Hunted by sentinels and faced with the end of her world, Days of Future Past’s Kate meets an old friend.

Stephen Strange, or one version of him at least, arrives with the mystical Black Priests from 2015’s Secret Wars and finds Kate cradling a dying Captain Marvel. Doctor Strange takes pity on an emotionally battered Kate and uses his powers to bring her on a journey of acceptance through alternate universes.

The point of these stories, and the point of X-Men: Incursions #1, is not always to resolve the problems the main characters are facing in their own lives but to find some level of acceptance (about their physical reality) in supernatural perspectives. The first alternate universe Doctor Strange takes Kate to the very reality her own is colliding with in its incursion. House of M, arguably one of her better lifetimes, where Kate teaches young mutants history at the “Charles F. Xavier Junior High School.”

It’s not like Kate can stay or interact with anyone, but the journey provides her with the knowledge that a better world (for her at least) does exist even if the one she knows is bleak and miserable by comparison. True to her character, Kate’s main concern during her and Strange’s journey is Carol, the last person she has left in her own reality.

 

Seeing Carol in her usual Captain Marvel getup is like a stimulant to Kate. Kate’s characterization changes in the dialogue to something more content and satisfied, even knowing how doomed things are back on her Earth.

Unfortunately, if you are familiar with 2015’s Secret Wars event, you may already know and dread where this is all going. Strange’s group, the Black Priests, he and Kate left back on her Earth, are multiversal surgeons. They use magic to destroy a dying universe before the effects of incursions can spread to the rest of the multiverse.

Jim Towe’s artwork is an excellent blend of iconic past styles tinged with the originality of a creative mind. There is attention to the small details and an eye for grandeur in the cosmic scale of the issue. Panels frequently overlay or cut in as sharp shifts to the scene or the moment.

The visual language Towe uses in the issue is more like a writer’s pen than a film camera. Small moments are captured in pieces that hammer in the emotional soul of the storyline. Tears and frowns are far more powerful than Sentinel lasers or magic spells capable of ripping the universe and putting it back together.

Fernando Sifuentes-Sujo brings a focus on lighting to that art. Characters, the colors they emit with their uncanny abilities, and the fate of worlds all cast hues on the art, which enhance the immersion and punch of the story.

Below is a mini-interview that Alex Paknadel, the writer of X-Men: Incursions #1, was kind enough to give me regarding this one-shot.

CW: House of M colliding with Days of Future Past is a hell of a hook. While you were working on this, what excited you most about having these characters interact?

AP: I think it was the contrast. Contrast always makes for great drama. Kate Pryde is the protagonist of the original Days of Future Past, but although she only appears briefly in House of M, we effectively see her living her best life. That was really my way in: If your life was a living hell, would the knowledge that a version of you was living very differently be a comfort or a curse?

CW: This is an ambitious one-shot. How did you plan to balance the quick pacing against the massive scale in this issue when you first sat down to write it?

AP: When dealing with a canvas as broad as this, I find it helpful to focus on one protagonist. There are three separate continuities in play here: Days of Future Past, House of M, and Secret Wars as the mechanism whereby the first two are placed on a collision course. The only way to address that in a one shot is to have one POV character and stick with them throughout.

CW: The ending was a really interesting way to wrap things up. At one point in the writing process did you first decide on that ending?

AP: Thank you! I kind of knew where I wanted to land with it pretty early on, and that was driven by a conviction that the stakes would have to be intensely personal throughout. Two universes colliding is huge, but unless you see it from the ground level – on an intimate scale – the emotional weight just isn’t going to land. I knew I needed all the pyrotechnics and whatnot, but it felt important to end it on a poignant note.

CW: Why did you choose to focus on Kitty Pryde and Doctor Strange when it came to choosing the perspective of this story?

AP: Kate Pryde was the logical choice because I knew I couldn’t spend equal time in both universes with the real estate that I had available to me. To make it a true crossover, it made sense to spend more time in House of M, albeit from the perspective of someone from Days of Future Past. Strange’s role as a kind of guide or Ghost of Christmas Past for Kitty was an obvious choice after I dug into his time with the Black Priests during Time Runs Out. He would have the means and the willingness to take Kate over to the House of M universe for a short time.

CW: In one of the alternate realities Kitty visits, one of the students is Mei from your Cyclops run. How did it feel to be able to bring back one of your own creations for a brief cameo?

AP: Mateo’s there too! Yeah, that was fun. Just a little easter egg for the deeply wonderful Cyclops: Seeing Red fans out there.

CW: When it comes to the artwork, which page did Jim (Towe) surprise you the most with?

AP: It was the introduction of the Black Priests. This one shot demanded a lot of him, not least in terms of honoring and homaging the styles of (among others) John Byrne, Simone Bianchi, and Olivier Coipel. Once I saw the Priests, I knew he was going to be able to blend all those styles seamlessly without sacrificing his own. Jim absolutely made this book his own, and I couldn’t have been more thrilled to work with him.

Final Thoughts

X-Men: Incursions #1 is a one-shot with surprising heart in its story. It tests the weight of the unbearable and considers the grand scheme of things in Marvel’s enormous ever-changing multiverse.

X-Men: Incursions #1: Kate, Ebeneezer, and a Strange Carol
  • Writing - 9/10
    9/10
  • Storyline - 8.5/10
    8.5/10
  • Art - 9/10
    9/10
  • Color - 8/10
    8/10
  • Cover Art - 7/10
    7/10
8.3/10
User Review
0 (0 votes)
Comments Rating 0 (0 reviews)
Exit mobile version