Batwoman #9
Recap
BATWOMAN, MURDERER. The events in Petalon have gone viral. With Batwoman seen gunning down three men on the street, Batman has questions. Now, as Kate prepares to return to her sister's side in Greece, Batman wants answers...and Batwoman may not be willing to answer them.
Eisner Award-winning writer Greg Rucka reunites with The Old Guard artist Leandro Fernández for an unforgettable new issue of the hit Next Level series that critics are calling “the Batwoman saga fans have been waiting for.”
Review
Batwoman #9 is a classic catch your breath and reestablish the status quo issue. Bad Seeds is over (not that Batwoman had very much to do with the event). Now Batwoman has to do what it seems like every Gotham hero (especially Bat family characters) has to do when visiting–face Batman. The big issue here: what is Batwoman doing with a gun?
Gun toting Bat characters are a big deal, regardless of whether they are ever fired. Red Hood’s periodic use of them is frequently a reason why he is an outcast among the Bat family. Rucka gives voice to Batman’s vehement opposition to them in Batwoman #9. For him, a gun is a symbol of a willingness to kill. There is no argument that will sway him otherwise. So what is Batwoman doing with one? Rucka leaves that somewhat unclear. That is not to say that it is unclear within the story, but that the character herself possesses a measure of uncertainty about using it. How much does she agree or disagree with Batman’s viewpoint? Does the mere possession of a gun translate to her willingness to kill?
This dialogue about guns feeds into a larger discussion in Batwoman #9–the responsibilities of someone wearing the Bat emblem. Batman reminds Batwoman that wearing the symbol means something and reflects on everyone else who does. This is actually an interesting if somewhat oblique continuation of a discussion Batwoman had with Huntress in Batwoman #8. In that case, Batwoman says, in regard to the TUCOs, “If you’re not serving something greater, then all you’re doing is playing dress-up for kicks.” Rucka turns that around, having Batman say essentially the same thing to her.
Interesting as this is, though, it is in some ways window dressing for the larger storylines involving Batwoman’s sister and a prophecy regarding Apokolips and a cult that worships Darkseid. These are the bigger plots that have been at the center of Batwoman since the series’ first issue. Rucka did a good job putting them on hold for the Bad Seeds tie-in issues, but he brings them back in force here. These are not the easiest storylines for new readers to invest in, and even using Batman as a sounding board against which these larger plot points can be bounced doesn’t quite solve this problem. Rucka is in danger of making the series too opaque.
Fernåndez’s style in Batwoman #9 is nicely tied into an issue that is largely an outdoor conversation. Lines are thick overall, but patches of shading are more restrained. While still black rather than a transition of grays, these relatively small patches of shading successfully delineate features, both on characters and backgrounds. This is especially useful with Batman who has the more intense side of the conversation for most of the issue. The darker highlights along his jawline and cheekbones emphasize the dialogue Rucka has written for him. Conversely, a lack of thick shadow gives Batwoman a softer look overall, both in facial expression and a more lithe appearance overall.
Hollingsworth’s color choices mesh well with Fernåndez’s art. The overall wider environment of Batwoman #9 relative to the previous two issues allows for brighter colors that create a wide open feel. Fernåndez’s thick lines aid in the color contrast which is actually on the lower side for most of the issue, with everything bathed in reds and oranges rather than blue light of day.
A late issue two page spread of chaotic panels sees Batwoman trigger an elaborate trap of laser beams that she must navigate before escaping from a collapsing cavern. This is a sound effects bonanza. Otsman-Elhaou fills the spread’s various panels with the sound effects, running them along the laser blasts and at points of impact before surrounding Batwoman with the sound effects of the collapsing cavern. The sound placement creates a scene of utter chaos.
Final Thoughts
Batwoman #9 does a good job forwarding Batwoman’s current character arc while tying it into the larger character ideals of Batman comics. Who is Batwoman in this moment? Does she even know? Less successful, and growing more so with each issue, is the ongoing storyline involving her sister and Apokolips.
Batwoman #9: Much Ado About a Gun
- Writing - 8.5/108.5/10
- Storyline - 7/107/10
- Art - 8/108/10
- Color - 7/107/10
- Cover Art - 7/107/10