DNX #5
Recap
Review
This is it, folks! The final fight for the future of Mutantkind! Original X-Man vs Original X-Man! Will Cyclops be able to stop the genetic bomb set by the original Beast? How will the events of this crossover affect what’s coming next? Will the Merry Mutants remain oh so merry? What could happen that will cause Jean to return to earth? You’ll have to read to find that out, you’re just here to read my thoughts, so let’s get on with it.
Jed MacKay has quickly had a through the Marvel writers hierarchy in an astonishingly quick time, and he’s been shouldering a lot of the big epics that we’ve seen since the From The Ashes era, with his run being considered the flagship book. This event is the culmination of the plots regarding the 3K’s sinister, Machiavellian plot to create more mutants with a mutant bomb, created by the original Beast, not the one plucked from the past who’s been on the team since the jump. It’s ’90s camp in every sense of the word.
Mackay adds a deeper, personal connection to this epic, by pulling on the reader’s heartstrings, by showing Scott’s thoughts on his and Beast’s relationship over the years. These two men are the founders, and they’re not just teammates, they’re family. Scott’s relationship to the O5 (technically O6 due to Sage’s spy status <snicker>) has always been the strongest. It’s a reminder of that. Scott has to be the one who takes Beast down. Beast is his responsibility, and if he should be put down, it should be his brother. MacKay’s playing on Of Mice and Men, where George had to put down by Lenny when he became too dangerous for others. It’s these types of internal conflicts that helped propel the X-Men into the comic’s stratosphere, and MacKay understands this. It’s why the X-Men have a deeper connection to its fans than run-of-the-mill superheroes, outside of maybe Spider-Man.
The ending sets up what’s coming next, and we see Jean, who’s been in outer space since this era began is now coming to earth, and heaven help anyone who stands in her way. It’s nice to see Jean finally returning to earth, and her family, especially since we haven’t seen much of her since the end of her solo book by Stephanie Phillips. Jean’s one of those characters who the writer either gets, or they don’t, so I’m anxiously awaiting to see how MacKay handles Jean, as well as how she interacts with the team. I have faith that MacKay will write her well, since I’ve enjoyed pretty much everyone else in the cast.
Federico Vicentini is on art here, and it’s quite enjoyable to read. His style is almost reminiscent of Joe Madureira, with that Western strain of anime. Real angular, with sharp lines that really conveys movement. The fight scene, as Cyckops and white Beast is kinetic, and you can feel the energy in each panel, I’m not overly familiar with his work, but i was quite impressed with what he gave us during this event, and hopes this was a try-out to replace Tony Daniel as the ongoing artist, with Daniel moving to Maximum X-Men next month.
Final Thoughts
With the culmination of the plots that have been brewing over the last several years, MacKay’s stories have finally paid off. While there were some pacing issues, and the tie-ins felt less integral to the overall story, was an interesting look into just how far our Beast has fallen. It’ll be interesting in where MacKay will go from here now that Jean is returning to the fold.
DNX #5: Hatfields vs. the McCoys
- Writing - 7.5/107.5/10
- Storyline - 7.5/107.5/10
- Art - 8/108/10
- Color - 8/108/10
- Cover Art - 7/107/10